Saturday, March 28, 2009
Picking Last and It Feels So Good!
The Steelers have 9 picks coming into this year’s draft, and I see them coming out of it with 1-2 OL, 2-3 DL, 1 WR, 1-2 DBs, and 1 LB. Onto the draft preview (order based on my personal preference).
1st round: Hakeem Nicks (WR – UNC), Tyson Jackson (DE – LSU), Vontae Davis (CB – Illinois), Alex Mack (C – Cal), or Max Unger (OL – Oregon)
Comment: Now, every yinzer that reads this pick is going to say the same thing here. “Why in the world do yinz have the Stillers pickin’ another WR when thez gotz so many needs at RB?” (Inside joke between Georgie and me). Here is my argument for this pick: I’ve seen Nicks play. End of discussion. Seriously. The guy is big, physical, and quick, and he has amazing hands. He immediately provides the Steelers with an heir apparent to Hines Ward, and he serves as an insurance policy in case Santonio Holmes demands a big payday in 2010 or Limas Sweed does not pan out. NOTE: I am a very big Sweed supporter, so I do not foresee scenario #2. Face it Yinzer Nation, the Steelers are now a passing team centered around an elite QB. They need 3-4 strong WRs to be effective.
Now, I do buy into the argument that any WR the team drafts should bring some return skills to the table, and Nicks does not fit this description. So, with that in mind, Tyson Jackson and Vontae Davis are my other two ideal 1st round picks. Jackson is a perfect fit as a 3-4 DE from a size/speed standpoint and Davis is a big and physical CB that would bring depth and youth to the defensive backfield. If either of these players is available at #32, they would be very good value picks.
Finally, we come to the most likely 1st round scenario, center Alex Mack from Cal. Justin Hartwig is over 30 and not the long-term solution at the position, and the Steelers have historically built their OL around a stalwart in the middle (Mansfield, Webby, Dirt, Hartings). Mack is a strong and powerful center that appears worthy of the position’s legacy in Pittsburgh.
All of the players profiled here are considered by most draft experts to fall anywhere in the 15-30 range. In light of that, I’ll add Max Unger as a possibility, since he should be there at 32. He is a talented and versatile offensive lineman that can play any of the 5 positions on the line, making him a great fit with Coach T’s mantra of “positional flexibility.”
One last 1st round note. I recently read a column by Mike Lombardi on National Football Post in which he stated that he did not feel Ray Maualuga, the all-world ILB from USC, was a 1st round pick. Now, Lombardi, as a former GM, is a trained expert and not just some middle-aged hack writer, so he should know what he's talking about. If for some reason Maualuga is sitting on the board at 32, everything you’ve read in the preceding paragraphs goes out the window. It's a no-brainer. The guy is a Ray Lewis-type talent at a position where the Steelers can never be deep enough. Yinzer Nation would whine and moan for the next ten years about selecting a 2nd 1st round LB in 3 years, but given James Farrior’s age and Maualuga’s singular talent, this pick just makes sense. I in no way, shape, or form expect him to be available at 32 though. Moving on…
2nd round: Sean Smith (CB – Utah), Duke Robinson (OG - Oklahoma), Ron Brace (DT – Boston College), or Herman Johnson (OG – LSU)
Comments: Sean Smith probably will not last until pick 64, so he may even be a round one option. He would be a great fit in the Steelers defensive backfield given his size (6'3", 210), athleticism (check this out), and versatility (there's that word again). DeShea Townsend is entering his 12 season, Ryan Clark is a free agent after the 2009 season, and Big Play Willie Gay is still relatively unproven. Smith would help alleviate all three of those concerns.
Anyone that watched the record-setting Oklahoma offense last year knows that Sam Bradford never got touched and DeMarco Murray seemingly always had room to run. Their offensive line, including massive guard Duke Robinson, was a large reason why. Robinson's size and reach make him a possibility at RT as well, allowing the Steelers to move Willie Colon inside where he belongs.
Ron Brace provides a succession plan for Casey Hampton and his pending free agency. Herman Johnson (6'7", 370+) earned his nickname "House" and is a high character guy who would be an absolute road grader in the running game.
3rd round: Marcus Freeman (LB – Ohio State), Derrick Williams (WR - PSU), Fili Moala (DT – USC), or Mitch King (DT – Iowa)
Comments: I want to focus on two players here: Marcus Freeman and Derrick Williams. While spending his college career overshadowed by teammate James Laurinaitis, Freeman always seemed to be around the ball in the OSU games I watched. He has the flexibility to play inside or outside, which is critical given James Harrison's contract situation, Larry Foote's 2010 free agency, and James Farrior's age.
Derrick Williams...DWill...Mr. #1 Recruit...I want to take this opportunity to personally apologize for spending the first three years of your college career as your biggest critic. Your senior year proved to me that any underperformance problems were strictly Morelli and Jay Paterno related. Williams possesses some key traits that make him an extremely attractive pick: fantastic hands, quickness, precise route-running, and, most importantly, big play ability in the return game. I would have knocked anyone out two years ago if they suggested DWill as a Steeler Day 1 pick, now I would applaud it.
Both King and Moala are undersized defensive tackles that are ideally suited to slide outside as 3-4 defensive ends.
4th round: Phil Loadholt (OT – Oklahoma), Brian Robiskie (WR – Ohio State), Juaquin Iglesias (WR – Oklahoma), or Victor Harris (CB – Virginia Tech)
Comments: Please see Duke Robinson above to understand Loadholt's appeal. Victor Harris is another CB option from a quality program, ditto for Juaquin Iglesias at WR/KR. That leaves Brian Robiskie for further analysis. Robiskie's numbers belie his abilities in my mind, given Ohio State's spotty QB play during his career. As you would expect from a coach's son, he's a smart, precise route runner with reliable hands. Similar to Nicks, I could see him as a suitable successor to Hines Ward in 2 years, serving as Ben's 3rd down security blanket. Robiskie has run well during his draft preparation, and he has 10 year pro written all over him.
5th round (a): Frank Summers (RB – UNLV), AQ Shipley (C – PSU), or Terrence Taylor (DT – Michigan)
Comments: Although I am baffled by Yinzer Nation's seemingly endless cry for RB help during this offseason, I have seen one mid-round RB/FB, Frank Summers, who would be a strong addition. I had not heard of this 250 bruiser until I read this article, but he could be another multi-faceted weapon for the Steeler offense. He adds a strong short-yardage presence to an already diverse backfield of FWP, Mendenhall, and Mewelde Moore.
AQ Shipley recently visited the Steelers facilities, signaling an interest in the Moon Township native. He's an intelligent and strong (33 reps at 225 lbs) option at center if the earlier rounds do not fall into place.
Terrence Taylor, another Big Ten product (shocking, I know), is a mid-round option at defensive tackle. This draft seems to really have a lot of quality depth at the key OL and DL positions, which should allow the team to focus on impact players on Day 1, regardless of position.
5th round (b): Maurice Evans (DE – PSU), Fenuki Tupou (OT – Oregon), Dannell Ellerbe (LB – Georgia), or Kyle Moore (DE – USC)
Comments: Let me first briefly comment on Tupou, Ellerbe, and Moore, all of whom are here based on position/need. They were all multi-year starters at big time college programs, and it seems logical to take this type of player in the middle rounds.
I want to now present a case for Maurice Evans, with a brief disclaimer. As a PSU alum, I have seen Evans a lot, so I am probably not a 100% objective evaluator. That aside, the guy is an athletic defensive end that probably has room to add 10-15 pounds of muscle, putting him in the ideal 3-4 range of 290. This pick, if by some crazy chance it happens, could be one of the best Day 2 picks of the Colbert era. I feel that strongly about this kid. He's gotten a very bad rap for what was essentially pretty harmless charge (possession of a small amount of wacky tobaccy), and once he got into JoePa's doghouse, his season was essentially finished. The emergence of Aaron Maybin during Evans' 3 game suspension only expedited his fate. As a Penn Stater, I 100% agreed with JoePa's decision to suspend him in light of the program's recent high-profile issues, but it does not change the fact that the guy can flat out play. Under Coach T's tutelage and guidance, the sky could be the limit. The problem is, some other smart team will probably have this same realization before the end of round 5.
Late Round Flyers: Jorvorskie Lane (FB - Texas A&M), Alex Boone (OT – Ohio State), Chase Daniel (QB - Missouri)
Thursday, June 5, 2008
In Full Bloom
Any respectable Pens fan knows how the next five years transpired. Fleury came to camp in August 2003 and performed so well in training camp that he forced GM Craig Patrick and coach Eddie Olyck to bring him to Pittsburgh to start the season. He set the league abuzz, until he was sent to the World Junior tournament in December and blew the tournament and his confidence in one dramatic week. Financial considerations forced the team to send him to Wilkes-Barre/Scranton upon his return, where he again struggled in the playoffs. In typical “yinzer” fashion, the poor kid starts getting slammed back in Pittsburgh as a bust. Mind you, he was 19 years old and had played a collective 20 games in the NHL, but the always perceptive Pittsburgh media and astute fans were writing him off.
Because of the lost '04-'05 season, the fortuitous deliverance of Sidney Crosby in the 2005 draft and the unceremonious ending to Le Manifique's career, Fleury's '05-'06 season is hazy to me. All I remember is that he continued to bounce between Wilkes-Barre and Pittsburgh and played inconsistent hockey. The criticism often heard focused on his over-reliance on athleticism, instead of proper positioning, his poor stick-handling, and his struggles in big games. Again, the kid was barely able to drink legally in the States. Did not matter, he was a wasted pick. I'm sure Bob Smizik did a 3,000 word column discussing how Fleury was responsible for the financial ruin and imminent departure of the team.
'06-'07 was a great bounce back year for the Penguins organization, but in my mind, Fleury's strong season got lost in the Crosby/Malkin shuffle. He posted the organization’s second 40 win season and collected 5 shutouts. He certainly struggled during the five game first-round beatdown by the Ottawa Senators in the playoffs, but he was not alone in that department. Again, as a 22 year old at the game's toughest position, he helped lead a 47 point turnaround culminating in the team's first playoff birth in five seasons.
I'm rambling here, but all of this background brings us to my main point. Game 5 of the 2008 Stanley Cup finals was one of the 4-5 most exciting Pittsburgh sporting events I have ever watched. And with all of the excitement and drama (Malone's return from a slap shot to a broken nose, Gonchar slamming his back saving a goal and returning to record the 2nd assist on Sykora's OT winner, Sykora telling NBC's Pierre McGuire that he was going to score the OT winner, Michel Theirren playing a "hunch" and inserting eventual goal-scorer Max Talbot as the 6th attacker at the end of regulation, Detroit almost winning it with a barrage during the last 34 seconds of regulation, Jarko "Pittsburgh's Favorite Player" Ruutu ringing the iron with a rocket in the 1st OT, etc) the thing that I was most excited about was the otherworldly performance turned in by the Flower.
To call his performance a "coming of age" doesn't do it justice. A 23 year old goalie made 55 saves in an elimination game on the road in the Stanley Cup finals. On national TV. Against a veteran laden juggernaut. And the numbers alone do not do justice to his performance. It was a thing of beauty. Among his 24 OT saves were some of the most spectacular I have ever seen. With the glove, with the skate, with the stick, with the blocker, on his back, on his stomach…you get the point. Even ever-sardonic Hockey Night in Canada analyst Don Cherry was practically beside himself with excitement on ESPN immediately after the game. He called Fleury's performance one of the best he's ever seen in his long career. This comment from the guy who used Mario Lemieux as a punching bag for years. Clearly not someone easily impressed.
It was gratifying as someone who believed in and defended this kid for 5 years to watch him stand on his head, put his team on his back, and refuse to lose that epic Game 5 in Detroit. Losing the Stanley Cup tonight was tough to take, but it is great to know as a Penguins fan that the team's young goalie has blossomed before our very eyes.
Monday, June 2, 2008
Game 4 and the Infamous 5 on 3
As a sports fan, there are certain moments that are etched in your brain for all time. If you're lucky, more of them are glorious than infamous. In honor the Penguins' woeful 5 on 3 power play late in their Game 4 loss in the Stanley Cup finals, here are the most crushing moments that stick out to me in my twenty-five or so years of rooting for the Pittsburgh sports franchises:
-1985 AFC Conference Championship - based on that fact that I was eight years old, I don't remember much about the game, but I distinctly remember this game being the first time I felt the letdown of a big lose.
-1992 NLCS, Game 7 - Stan Belinda, Barry Bonds, and Francisco Cabrera are usually discussed in reference to this game, but the play that sticks out for me was Jose "Chico" Lind booting an easy ground ball with no outs in the bottom of the 9th. Jim Leyland proceeds to pull Doug Drabek, giving way to Belinda and history. I will go to my grave contending that Drabek would have finished the game and the Pirates would have won the World Series if the usually reliable Lind does not boot that ball.
-1993 Patrick Division Finals, Game 7 - I walked around in a daze for weeks after Ray Ferraro found Dave Volek in OT to end the dream of a Pens three-peat. That 1993 team was by far the best of the 1990's dynasty, but it could not overcome the fatigue of their record season-ending streak.
-1995 AFC Conference Championship - the sight of Alfred Pupunu streaking past Tim McKyer still haunts my dreams.
-Super Bowl XXX (1996) - it's funny, the moment that stands out for me in this game Levon Kirkland's huge sack on 3rd down to take the Cowboys out of field goal range late in the fourth quarter. That play should have set up the Steelers to run the ball right down the 'Boys throats (Bam Morris was fantastic in the 2nd half) for a four minute drive to seal the victory. Instead, Bill Cowher and Ron Erhardt decide to get cute and go five wide, thus Neil O'Donnell's place in Pittsburgh sports infamy.
-1998 AFC Conference Championship - the sight of Bill Romanowski mocking Kordell Stewart after his end zone interception right before halftime always brings back that nauseous feeling.
-2000 Eastern Conference Finals, Game 4 - Keith Primeau, five overtimes, enough said.
-2002 AFC Conference Championship - Stewart usually gets the lion's share of the ridicule for this game, and rightfully so, but if Troy "the Bust" Edwards doesn't run out of bounds on Josh Miller's 70+ yard punt, the Steelers face the Rams in Super Bowl XXXVI.
-2005 AFC Conference Championship - sensing a painful trend? Ugh. Two moments stand out from this horror show. First, watching Rodney Harrison very…slowly…return a Ben Roethlisberger interception 87 yards for a touchdown was a kick in the shin. Second, the one guy that perpetually drove me insane during his career, Plaxico Burress, drops a gimme touchdown to pull within seven in the fourth quarter. Fitting ending to his Steeler career.
Shockingly, there is only one Pirates moment here…
Thursday, May 29, 2008
Mario and the Media
I'm not sure what audience Burnside intends to appease, but I just don't see the purpose of ripping an icon during the team's return to glory. And to suggest that Lemieux is some self-serving manipulator of the media is absurd in this instance. He has clearly stated that he does not want to take attention and focus off of the team's success, and he's smart enough to realize his stepping into spotlight would steal attention from Crosby and the rest of this series' young stars. He understands the significance to the city, team, and league of continuing the national drumbeat for the new NHL, and he knows that Crosby is the face of that movement.
Of course, not to be outdone, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's ever cheery Ron Cook concurred with Burnside in his column today. The funny part is, Cook managed to squeeze in his praise for Burnside in a column about Crosby's superstar effort in Game 3. Good to see Cook knows how to stay on point. Again, I just can't understand taking pot shots at a guy that has saved the franchise on THREE separate occasions. Has he historically been surly with the media? Sure. Was his interest in ownership of the team largely based on his vested financial stake? Without a doubt. Did he use the media (and some other cities) as an instrument for gaining a new arena deal? Thank goodness yes. Is any of this relevant during what should be a fun, entertaining, and galvanizing playoff run that the city and region can rally around? Absolutely not.
It's good to see that petty media grudges never die...
Late to the blog game...
Monday, April 30, 2007
2007 NFL Draft Preview....Posted Afterwards (from Three Hamiltons blog)
As the 2007 NFL Draft is quickly approaching (only 10 more excruciating days), I felt it was time to kick start the Three Hamiltons blog, especially considering the place it holds in my sporting heart. I thought my format last year worked out okay, so I’m rolling with the same thing this year. Again, I’ll be focusing on the first draft of the Mike Tomlin era in Steeltown. This draft is crucial in adding some depth to bounce back from a topsy-turvy 2006 campaign. Looking back on last year’s picks, this exercise is in vain, but it is fun anyway.
1st round: Paul Posluszny (OLB – the ol’ Alma Mater)
Comment: As I’m sure everyone is sick of hearing me say, there is no player that is a better fit for everything that Mike Tomlin is going to instill in this Steelers team. Toughness – check. Ridiculous Work Ethic – check. Proto-typical WLB in the
2nd round: Dwayne Jarrett (WR - USC), Brian Leonard (RB – Rutgers), Tony Hunt (RB –
Comments: This 2nd round pick was the toughest for me to pinpoint. This draft seems really deep from late 1st to mid-3rd, so there are going to be some talented players here. The national media has had rumblings of Jarrett falling recently, but I cannot see him dropping to #46. That being said, he would be amazing as the final link in the Steelers new 4 WR offense under new offensive coordinator Bruce Arians. They clearly will be targeting WRs because of this slight shift in offensive philosophy, and given the WR talent available in this slot, this pick seems like the logical place. Rice and Davis are both the type of tall, deep threat WRs that would compliment the gritty Hines Ward and quick Santonio Holmes. That being said, I think Brian Leonard would be a great “Ultraback” player to compliment Fast Willie Parker (God bless Raymont Harris, wherever you are). Leonard is a strong enough runner to spell Parker for 8-12 carries a game, and he is the ideal 3rd down back given his pass-catching and pass blocking skills. Deuce
3rd round: Chris Henry (RB -
Comments: Henry’s size (230)/speed (4.38) combination at the combine really intrigues me, but his college stats seem very sparse. This pick really is contingent on the 2nd round pick. I cannot see them getting through the first four rounds without taking a LB, RB, and WR. That being said, if some talent at CB (Wade), DE (Moses) or LB (Woodley) slide to this part of the 3rd round, it would make sense to grab them. These three particular players were all high performers at major programs and would be a good fit for the Steelers slight shift in defensive scheme.
4th round (a): Daniel Sepulveda (P – Baylor), Kareem Brown (DT – the U), or Kevin Kolb (QB - Houston)
Comments: Punter Chris Gardocki has long outlived his usefulness, so, barring Josh Miller getting cut by
4th round (b): Dwayne Wright (RB –
Comments: Again, Wright’s size and battering ram style are intriguing as a complement to Parker. Abbate again fits the blue collar LB style syonomous with the Steelers and has the look of a very strong special teams contributor. Marvel Smith’s age necessitates the adding of some OT depth, and Marten looks like another in a long line of solid OL from the
Late Round Flyers: Tyler Palko (QB - Pitt), Jason Snelling (RB - Virginia), Zac DeOssie (LB - Brown), or Jacoby Jones (WR - Lane)
Saturday, May 13, 2006
Please save us Mr. Cuban!! (from Three Hamiltons blog)

I am sure there is no way Mark Cuban would ever find his way to this blog, but I am going to make my plea anyway, if only to make myself feel better. As I watch the Pittsburgh Pirates' 14th straight losing season unfold, I feel like a rubber-necker watching another car wreck on the Parkway East. It is during this time of year, May - when the Pirates are officially out of contention, that my thoughts return to the annual dream of Mark Cuban, a Pittsburgh area native, riding in on a white horse (or Humvee, if he so chooses) and purchasing the team from the clutches of evil Kevin McClatchy and the non-existent Nutting family. Clearly, they do not have the financial or marketing clout to save this team from the baseball abyss in which it currently resides.
There is ZERO doubt in my mind that Mr. Cuban has both the money and passion to build a winning franchise again in the great city of Pittsburgh. He is a smart enough businessman to realize that all of the variables are place for a very successful situation. The team already has one of the 2-3 best ballparks in all of baseball, they compete in the less rugged National League, and they have a solid farm system from which to start. There is one other factor though that I think is the most important. There is a great, loyal fan base just waiting for a winner.

Now, it goes without saying that Pittsburgh is a football town. I mean, the dungeon that was Three Rivers Stadium, God rest its soul, was sold out even during the terrible end of the Noll era, when Walter Abercrombie and Mark Malone passed as stars (ahhhhhhhh....bad flashbacks...think Super Bowl XL, Hines Ward, Big Ben...that's better...sorry for the tangent). But, I firmly believe that Pirates fans are just so beaten down by what amounts to 25 years of horrid baseball, that they are just tired and waiting for a savior. When you think about the fact that, save the nice six year run during the Bonds/Leyland/LaValliere era of 1988-1993, these fans have been subject to horrible baseball for a VERY long time. I mean, do the names Jason Thompson, Sammy Khalifa, Mike Kingery, Jacob Brumfield, and John Wehner mean anything to you? Didn't think so.
All we want is hope. Seriously. I have no doubt that, if Cuban bought the team, interest in the Pirates would shoot through the roof, even before the winning started. And, with Cuban, the winning would start pretty quickly. He is not afraid to lose some money for a few years to win back the fans and win games. Everyone forgets what a joke the Mavericks were prior to his ownership. They were every bit as pathetic as the Clippers were until recently. Now, they are perennially one of the top 3-4 teams in the league and sell out every game. I can speak from experience, having attended a Mavs/Pacers game over Christmas, their game experience is second to none. The arena is amazing, the fans are so engaged, and the atmosphere is electric.
Let's face it, Pittsburgh sports fans are a) savvy, b) impatient, and most importantly, c) not rich enough to throw cash away. For the past 14 years, being a diehard Pirates fan means throwing money away. I know from personal experience as, prior to moving to Boston in 2001, my buddies and I spent usually 2 nights during each homestand trekking to Three Rivers Stadium with roughly 7,000-10,000 other poor diehards just out to support our team. Even since my move, while watching the Red Sox go through a renaissance, my allegiance has never waived (though I will admit to following the Sox also, based on a childhood fascination with Clemens, Greenwell, Big Mo, and the fact that living here requires you know all things Sox). The first thing I do every morning is check out the prior night Buccos score/recap, which usually prompts a day long email discussion with those same Pittsburgh buddies about the good, bad, and ugly of another lost season. Heck, I have even convinced my ever-understanding wife to let me spend an extra $10 a month on our DirecTV package at our new house, just so I can get the regional sports package with FSN Pittsburgh to watch the games!! (NOTE: the reason I am getting DirecTV in the first place though is to get the NFL Sunday Ticket to follow the Super Bowl Champion Pittsburgh Steelers).
I refuse to believe that my buddies and I are the only fans like this out there. When I listen to my father, who never really waxes nostalgic about sports, talk about going to Forbes field to see the great Roberto Clemente, Elroy Face, Bill Mazeroski, Dick Groat, listening to the legendary voice of Bob Prince, and following the great 70's teams with "Pops" Stargell and Kent Tekulve, there is clearly a strong fanbase out there waiting for a return to those days. Heck I can even remember watching the Leyland teams with my grandma on hot summer nights, because they had cable and we didn't, and she always loved watching the games. And, I am convince that if Mark Cuban bought the team, fans would return in droves, bringing that dampened spirit back with them. Pittsburgh has the potential to be a two-sport town, all we need is a reason to believe.